71 PLYMOUTH Avenue, St. Catharines
For sale · $489,000
4 beds · 2 baths · Detached · 1100-1500 sq ft
About this home
Welcome to 71 Plymouth Ave - a move-in ready, versatile detached home situated on an oversized double corner lot in St. Catharines. Offering two self-contained living spaces with separate private entrances, full kitchens and bathrooms, this property is ideal for multi-generational living, an owner-occupier looking to offset monthly costs, or a turn-key investment opportunity with strong rental potential. The main level offers a spacious 3-bedroom + den/flex layout, while the lower level features a separate 1-bedroom living space with its own entrance, kitchen and bathroom. Previously rented for approximately $2,600/month upstairs and $1,500/month downstairs, for a combined historical rental income of approximately $4,100/month. Approximately $12,000 in recent upgrades and improvements, including a new Lennox furnace (2025), fresh interior paint (2026), newer washer, updated HVAC wiring and Google Nest thermostat. The oversized double corner lot also offers exciting future extension, redevelopment or additional residential potential, with nearby precedent, subject to municipal approvals and buyer due diligence. Large yard, double driveway with parking for up to 4 vehicles, and convenient access to the QEW, transit, shopping and amenities. Some photos are virtually staged.
Listing details
- MLS® number: X13804448
- Listed on September 18, 2026
- 29 photos
Listing brokerage: BLUE WHALE CAPITAL REALTY INC.
See every photo, drive times from your places, the neighbourhood and nearby schools in the Dibz app. Sold prices and listing history are for signed-in members.
Open the map · Homes for sale in St. Catharines · Book a showing
MLS® listing data by PropTx under licence from TRREB, deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx. Operated by HighPoint Homes Realty, Brokerage.